Thursday 25 July 2024

Smothermoss by Alisa Alering - Book Review

 


'Ferns grow knee-deep along the shoulder, laced with briars and unripe raspberries, so thick they could hide a bear. Could hide anything, really.

'In 1980s Appalachia, life isn’t easy for Sheila. She endures relentless taunting and bullying at the hands of her classmates; she takes care of her great-aunt, the garden and home, and the rabbits; and forages for mushrooms in the forest, all while her mother works long, back-breaking shifts at the nearby state asylum. But it’s her peculiar little sister, Angie, who worries her the most. Angie is obsessed with nuclear war, Rambo, zombies, a Russian invasion of their community, and the ominous, tarot-like cards that she creates that somehow speak to her. As if all that weren’t enough, Sheila feels an unexplainable weight around her neck. Is it the ancient and strange mountain that they live on that casts its shadow on her, or something or someone else unknown? Unseen?

'When a pair of female hikers are brutally murdered on the nearby Appalachian trail, Sheila and Angie find themselves inexorably drawn into the hunt for the killer. As the ever-present threat of violence looms larger, the mountain might be the only thing that can save them from the darkness consuming their home and their community.'

Appalachia is a place where I'm used to seeing horror; it's a creepy setting that writers have returned to time and time again over the years. And whilst I'm used to seeing it in a historical setting Smothermoss surprised me by being a more modern Appalachian horror; though the 1980's is now classed as a historical setting and that alone feels like something that should elicit horror.

Smothermoss tells the story of two teenage sisters, Sheila and Angie. Sheila is the older of the two, seventeen years old, and lives with her thirteen year old sister Angie, their great aunt, and their mother. Whilst their mother is out working every hour she can get at the local asylum Sheila has to step up and run the household. Added on top of this, the family is poor, struggling to get by, and Sheila is the target of relentless bullying by her peers. Life isn't great for her. When two young women are murdered close to their home on the remote mountain trail, Sheila and Angie set out to find out what happened.

Despite having a relatively short length of just over two hundred and fifty pages, Smothermoss never feels light, and Alisa Alering packs a lot into the pages of her debut novel. However, there are times where there was so much happening within the book that I did on occasion feel a little lost, and wondered if perhaps I was missing some details or two. This could also be down to the fact that there's a lot of strangeness in Smothermoss, the kind of horror that blurs the lines between real and the bizarre, and leaves you questioning if what you read was real, or simply the strange imaginings of our central characters.

The book is very dark too, and there's a heavy tone to it from the very first few pages. The atmosphere is bleak, and at times outright oppressive, and despite our characters living out in the beuatiful nature of Appalachia it feels more claustrophobic than you'd think. Nature is less something of beauty here, and more of an oppressive and even brutal force that shapes the lives of all those who live within in. There are few moments to be found where our characters get a chance to smile or joke around, and the joy that does happen is so fleeting it almost feels like it doesn't happen. This somewhat plays into the imaginary worlds that play a large part in the narrative, ways in which Sheila and Angie are able to escape from the horror and misery of their everyday life.

Magic realism is a bit part of the story, and because of this it can sometimes be hard to discern if things are real or not. Is there really an invisible, magical rope around Sheila's neck that ties her to the mountains, or is this just her imagination conjuring a metaphor for her situation? The book doesn't really provide an answer, or at least one that I picked up on, and as such leaves a lot down to the readers to decide. You can come away from Smothermoss having experienced a story steeped in the magical and mystical, whilst another person can read the book and dismiss a lot of those moments as simply not being real. It's a novel that each reader is going to get something a little different from. 

The novel also has a lot of themes for growing up, for navigating teenage life, and exploring queerness and gender identity and expression. But it also feels a little like Alering was a bit reluctant to fully explore this in any great depth. Again, much like the supernatural side of things, readers can come away with different reads on the characters and their journeys, and the reluctance to take a firm stance means that some important themes can likely be easily brushed off, seen more as audience projection that actual content within the book. 

I'm still not sure exactly how I feel about Smothermoss. There are a lot of parts that I really liked, whilst there were others that I failed to connect with and didn't really understand. Despite being a short book it felt like a long, heavy read at times, and there was certainly a lot going on within the pages. Smothermoss might really connect with you, however, and the fact that it didn't with me is by no means a condemnation of it. I'm probably just not the ideal reader for it; but there will absolutely be readers out there that are going to love it. 



Support Amy on Patreon

Buy Amy A Coffee

Go to Amy's Blog

No comments:

Post a Comment